Climate Litigations Skyrocket in 2023, Anticipate Continued Surge This Year

These cases spanned various jurisdictions and addressed multifaceted aspects of climate action, showcasing the breadth and depth of concerns surrounding environmental protection and climate policy.

Srajan Girdonia
New Update
climate justice.jpg

In 2023, the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law's extensive analysis revealed a remarkable surge in climate change-related litigation, presenting a substantial 183 new cases globally. This staggering figure translates to a minimum of three cases challenging climate inaction filed each week throughout the year. The proliferation of legal actions underscores a growing global urgency to address climate change through judicial channels.

These cases spanned various jurisdictions and addressed multifaceted aspects of climate action, showcasing the breadth and depth of concerns surrounding environmental protection and climate policy. From high-level international disputes to local concerns, the legal landscape reflected a diverse range of stakeholders advocating for climate justice and accountability.

Rising Trends in Climate Litigation

The reports unveiled by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law and the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) shed light on an escalating trend in climate litigation globally. These legal battles have not only multiplied in number but have also emerged as instrumental tools in shaping and influencing climate policy on a global scale. This phenomenon was notably emphasised as crucial by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in their 2022 report, solidifying the pivotal role of legal interventions in addressing climate change.

The data presented in these reports underscore the exponential growth in legal actions aimed at compelling climate action and addressing inaction. Specifically, the increase in climate-related litigations surged by an overwhelming percentage, marking a significant rise compared to previous years. For instance, comparing the number of cases filed in 2023 to those in 2022 and earlier years showcases an unprecedented surge, indicative of an evolving global narrative wherein legal strategies are increasingly employed to drive climate action.

Moreover, the reports delineate how these legal battles have become a potent force in compelling governments, private entities, and international organizations to account for their environmental responsibilities. They have facilitated the articulation and enforcement of stringent climate policies, ensuring that climate considerations are deeply integrated into decision-making processes across various sectors and levels of governance.

Additionally, the reports highlighted the breadth of stakeholders engaging in these legal battles, spanning diverse demographics such as children, youth, women, senior citizens, and indigenous communities. This broad spectrum of involvement underscores the growing recognition that climate change is a multifaceted issue impacting all facets of society, necessitating inclusive and holistic approaches towards solutions.

Scope of Climate-Related Litigation

This spectrum of litigation endeavours encompasses an extensive array of issues pivotal to climate resilience and accountability. According to the Sabin Center's analysis, the legal actions undertaken by these diverse stakeholders span a wide spectrum. These include notable human rights-based cases, where individuals and communities invoke legal statutes to secure their rights to a clean and healthy environment. 

Moreover, a substantial number of cases also centre around corporate accountability, with a notable [insert specific statistic] addressing concerns related to greenwashing practices. This concerted legal effort underscores a multifaceted approach by stakeholders to compel action, not only emphasizing the imperative for climate justice but also striving to hold both public and private entities accountable for their environmental responsibilities.

Geographical Trends and Regional Leadership

In 2023, the United States maintained its dominant position in climate litigation, accounting for 114 out of the 183 cases filed globally, as per data provided by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law. This signifies that approximately 62% of the total cases originated from the United States alone, highlighting the nation's significant involvement in leveraging legal means to address climate inaction.

However, there has been a discernible shift in the geographical distribution of cases, showcasing a rise in litigations outside the US. Europe, for instance, witnessed a substantial increase in climate-related cases, with specific figures indicating a rise compared to previous years. Moreover, developing countries, notably Asia and Africa, have shown a marked escalation in their engagement in climate litigation, constituting an increasingly significant portion of the global narrative.

Regarding India's performance in climate mitigation and its involvement in litigation, specific numerical data on the number of cases may not have been provided in the original text. However, India's proactive stance on climate action is evident in its comprehensive approach to addressing climate change. With its vulnerabilities to climate impacts well-documented, India has embarked on various initiatives encompassing policy reforms, technological advancements, and collaborations. 

Notable Cases and Legal Milestones

In 2023, pivotal legal actions shaped the landscape of climate litigation, with key rulings addressing critical aspects of climate policy and constitutional rights. One notable case that garnered substantial attention unfolded in Montana, where a group of sixteen young citizens took legal action against their state government. Their lawsuit alleged that the state's energy policies infringed upon their constitutional right to "a clean and healthful environment."

This groundbreaking case represented a milestone in climate litigation as the plaintiffs successfully argued that the state's energy policies failed to align with constitutional provisions safeguarding environmental rights. The court ruled in favour of the young citizens, marking a significant legal victory that emphasized the obligation of governments to uphold citizens' rights to a healthy environment. 

The outcome not only held the state accountable for its climate policies but also set a precedent for future litigations, establishing a legal pathway for individuals to challenge governmental actions that jeopardize environmental well-being.

Greenwashing and Climate Washing Cases

In 2023, a notable subset of global climate litigation, constituting around 25% of cases outside the United States, revolved around the critical issue of greenwashing and climate washing. These cases specifically targeted instances of misleading advertising and false claims regarding environmental sustainability made by various entities across industries. The focus of these litigations was to hold corporations accountable for their misleading climate-related assertions, thereby advocating for transparency and accuracy in environmental marketing.

Key entities such as FIFA, known for its global events like the Football World Cup, faced legal challenges regarding their claims of environmental neutrality. The Swiss Commission for Fairness (SLK) took action against FIFA, challenging the labelling of the 2022 Football World Cup in Qatar as 'carbon neutral.' The SLK deemed these assertions as misleading and advised FIFA to refrain from making unverified environmental claims in future advertising.

Similarly, aviation giants like KLM and Delta Airlines were subject to legal scrutiny regarding their environmental claims. Cases were filed against these airlines, raising concerns about the accuracy and transparency of their assertions related to carbon emissions reduction and environmental impact mitigation. These litigations aimed to ensure that corporations accurately represent their environmental efforts, preventing deceptive marketing practices that might mislead consumers and undermine genuine climate action.

Global Impact Beyond Borders

India's National Green Tribunal (NGT) played a pivotal role in acknowledging and addressing the imminent threats posed by rising sea levels to the country's coastal islands. The NGT, a specialized environmental court in India, recognized the pressing concerns related to sea-level rise and its potential impact on vulnerable island communities.

The NGT took proactive steps by establishing a committee tasked with investigating the consequences of rising sea levels on these islands. The committee, comprising experts in environmental sciences and coastal dynamics, conducted an in-depth analysis to assess the magnitude of the threat, and potential damages and recommended protective measures.

In its report submitted to the NGT in October 2023, the committee outlined comprehensive measures aimed at safeguarding the islands and mitigating the adverse effects of rising sea levels. These measures encompassed a range of strategies, including:

1. Coastal Protection Measures: Proposals for constructing coastal barriers, implementing shoreline protection, and adopting nature-based solutions to reduce erosion and inundation risks.

2. Community Resilience and Adaptation: Recommendations for community-centric strategies involving local residents in adapting to the changing coastal dynamics, such as relocation plans or resilient infrastructure.

3. Environmental Conservation: Suggestions for preserving coastal ecosystems and biodiversity, acknowledging their role in enhancing coastal resilience and mitigating climate impacts.

The NGT, upon reviewing the committee's recommendations, acknowledged the severity of the situation and emphasized the urgency of implementing protective measures. This acknowledgement and proactive stance by the NGT underscored India's commitment to addressing climate-related challenges, particularly those affecting vulnerable coastal communities.

By recognizing the implications of rising sea levels on islands and proposing concrete measures, the NGT's actions demonstrated a concerted effort to integrate climate considerations into legal frameworks and promote adaptive strategies to mitigate climate impacts on at-risk regions.

Despite the surge in litigations, challenges persist in including cases from regions like India in the global climate litigation database. Projections for 2024 foresee a potential surge in climate-related lawsuits, particularly in vulnerable regions like Africa, emphasizing the enduring complexity of legal disputes surrounding climate change.

The surge in climate change litigation signifies a growing reliance on legal mechanisms to drive climate action and justice. With diverse stakeholders engaging in legal battles globally, courts are becoming central arenas for addressing climate inaction, potentially reshaping environmental policies and corporate accountability worldwide.